Australia's Carbon Leakage Review put the problem it was asked to solve at up to 1.5 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent a year shifting offshore by 2030, around 0.3 percent of national emissions in 2023, with modeled effects on real GDP ranging from roughly zero to a decline of 0.002 percent.
It recommended a border carbon adjustment anyway. The government has not agreed to one.
That gap between a small measured problem and a substantial proposed instrument is where the Safeguard Mechanism review now sits. The review opened on 7 August 2026, submissions closed on Friday 18 September, and the department's consultation paper treats a border adjustment as a potential mechanism rather than a decision ta
The Review's Scope And Limits
Two sentences in the consultation paper do more to set expectations than anything else. The review is "not intended to make fundamental reforms" to the Safeguard's design, and changes will generally take effect from 1 July 2030.
Its job is to assess whether the 2023 reforms are working as intended and are calibrated to meet 2030 targets, and to advise on post-2030 settings and on the Safeguard's share of the 2035 target. The objectives sit in section 3(2) of the National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting Act 2007, and the review's timing and scope come from the explanatory statement to the 2023 legislation.
Completion is set for 2026-27, with a government position paper planned for early the following year and draft legislation carrying administrative amendments expected early next year.
So a facility reading this for operational consequences in 2027 or 2028 will mostly find none. The decisions being taken are about the decade after.
The Current Settings
The Safeguard covers facilities emitting more than 100,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent a year, about 30 percent of national emissions. The reporting scheme underneath it has a facility threshold of 25,000 tonnes.
Covered facilities fell from 219 in 2022-23 to 208 in 2024-25, a drop of about 5 percent. Baselines decline by 4.9 percent a year, taking covered emissions from 139 million tonnes in 2023 to 100 million by 2030, an 8 percent reduction.
Trade-exposed baseline adjustments run in three-year terms. A manufacturer qualifies when scheme costs exceed 3 percent of earnings before interest and tax, with a minimum decline rate of 1 percent, available when costs reach 10 percent of EBIT. A non-manufacturer qualifies above 3 percent, with a minimum 2 percent rate at 8 percent. Three manufacturing facilities hold that status, about 11 percent of the population, and no non-manufacturing facility does.
The cost containment measure started at 75 dollars per credit in 2023-24 and rises by the consumer price index plus 2 percent. In percent, it sat at 82.68 dollars against an average spot price of 36.99, a premium of about 1124 percent, and no purchases have been made under it. Government holdings are around 5.5 million credits, possibly reaching 26 million by 2030, against projected demand of 26 million in 2030 and 35 million in 2035.
ACCU Limits
This is the live question for anyone currently meeting obligations with credits rather than abatement.
In 2024, facilities surrendered 10.8 million Australian carbon credit units against 2.6 million safeguard mechanism credits, a ratio of about four to one. Around 10 percent of facilities surrendered credits above 30 percent of their baseline: 18 facilities in 2023-24, rising to 23 in 2024-25.
The paper asks whether new measures are needed to limit credit use and accelerate industrial decade decarbonization, and if so, in what form and from when. Three options are named: quantitative limits on how many credits can be surrendered, discounting so that more than one credit must be surrendered per tonne of exceedance, and vintage restrictions. It also asks whether carbon abatement plans should be required.
Discounting is the one to watch, because it changes the economics without changing the rules about who can use credits. A ratio above one to one makes credits a worse deal per tonne than abatement at a given cost, which is the effect the objectives call for without the administrative edges of a hard cap.
International Units And Onsite Abatement
On international units, the paper states its default plainly: it does not propose introducing them. Any future use would be confined to high-integrity units under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement. The questions are whether there is ongoing interest and why, and what the market would need in terms of interoperability, recognition,n and integrity before inclusion could even be considered.
Read that as a door left ajar rather than opened. For a company modeling future compliance costs, the planning assumption should be domestic units only.
On onsite abatement, the statutory objectives require a material incentive for action at the facility and gross emissions falling on a five-year rolling average. The paper asks whether current settings and government support are adequate, including sector-specific barriers, and, more pointedly, whether credit limits, trade-exposed eligibility or other settings actively discourage onsite action. That last question invites an argument that the concessions designed to protect competitiveness are also protecting inaction.
The Border Adjustment Proposal
The Carbon Leakage Review, commissioned in November 2023, recommends a border carbon adjustment for a small set of high-risk commodities rather than a broad measure.
The design mirrors the domestic scheme. A carbon liability would apply to imports, reflecting domestic obligations and covering Scope 1 emissions consistent with the Safeguard. Liability would be calculated on emissions above a benchmark and on the gap between the origin country's effective carbon price and an Australian benchmark. Importers could pay, or surrender Australian carbon credit units. The review also recommends streamlined reporting, independent verification and default emissions values.
Two design choices matter more than the rest. The review does not support export rebates, which distinguishes it from schemes that compensate exporters for domestic carbon costs. And trade-exposed baseline assistance would be removed for a commodity once the border adjustment is fully implemented for it, making the two instruments alternatives rather than a stack.
Cement and clinker come first, chosen for data availability and market structure. Later candidates named are lime, steel, glass, and ammonia and its derivatives, with hydrogen also mentioned. No commencement dates are given, and implementation is described as needing time for detailed design, administrative systems, and further consultation.
Why Coverage And The Border Tax Are One Question
Here is the connection most coverage misses, and it comes from the department's own paper.
The Carbon Leakage Review found that partial Safeguard coverage in lime, treated flat steel, pulp and paper, and glass could limit a border adjustment's scope, because such a mechanism would ideally mirror requirements placed on most or all Australian producers of the commodity. If only the largest plants in a sector carry a domestic carbon cost, charging importers to match that cost is difficult to justify and easy to challenge. This makes the coverage threshold a border-tax question rather than an administrative one. The paper floats that a threshold of 75,000 tonnes, a quarter below the current level, "may help to manage competitive distortions," while suggesting that dropping to 25,000 would not generate abatement worth the compliance burden on smaller facilities. And it says explicitly that the timing of a lower threshold could be considered alongside the timing of a potential border adjustment.
So the sequence runs in one direction. Broader domestic coverage first, border adjustment second. A company arguing about either should understand it is arguing about both.
What It Means For Importers And Exporters
For anyone selling cement or clinker into Australia, the proposed design has three features worth understanding well before any commencement date exists.
Liability would be calculated on emissions above a benchmark, not on total embedded emissions, so a producer operating below the benchmark faces a smaller charge or none. That makes verified product-level emissions data commercially valuable, not merely administrative.
The charge would then be reduced by the effective carbon price already paid in the country of origin. An exporter shipping from a jurisdiction with its own compliance carbon price would face a narrower gap than one from a jurisdiction without, and the size of that advantage depends on how an effective price is calculated, which the design does not yet settle.
And default emissions values would apply where data is absent. Defaults in schemes of this kind are typically set conservatively, meaning a producer that cannot evidence its actual intensity is likely to be charged as though it were worse than average.
For Australian exporters, the news is less welcome. The review does not support export rebates, so a domestic producer carrying Safeguard costs would not be compensated when selling into markets without an equivalent carbon price. That is a deliberate design choice rather than an oversight, and it is one of the clearest differences from schemes operating elsewhere.
What Happens Next
The post-2030 numbers are the substance of this review, and the paper sets out how they will be derived.
Australia's 2035 target is a 62 to 70 percent reduction from 2005 levels. The government proposes retaining the proportional share approach, and updating the Safeguard share from 28.1 percent to 29.8 percent would produce a 2035 point target of roughly 54.3 to 68.8 million tonnes and a five-year emissions budget of about 369.3 to 412.8 million tonnes across 2030-31 to 2034-35, averaging around 74 to 83 million tonnes a year.
The paper also suggests the Safeguard target could sit near the bottom of that range, while the decline rate tracks closer to the top. The decline rate for 2030-31 to 2034-35 will be set once the 2035 target is fifinalized, takingnto account production growth, concessional baselines, policy changes areand reserves hen wie review cowill nsider the rate from 2035 to 2050.
For a covered facility, three things follow. The 2030 settings are largely fixed, so near-term planning does not change. The credit question is where this review could bite hardest, and a discounting mechanism would reprice every tonne currently covered by purchased units. And if your commodity appears on the border adjustment list, the trade-exposed assistance you rely on is proposed to end when that mechanism arrives.
Position as of 16 November 2026. The review's scope, dates, current settings and consultation questions are taken from the department's Safeguard Mechanism Review consultation paper of August 2026; the Carbon Leakage Review's recommendations are taken from a professional firm analysis of that review published on 19 February 2026, not from the final report itself, which was not reachable from the research environment used. Figures are reproduced as those documents state them and percentages, ratios and averages derived from them are the author's own arithmetic. A consultation paper sets out options and questions rather than decisions: nothing described here is settled policy, the government has not committed to a border carbon adjustment, no commencement dates have been announced for one, and the review's outcome may differ from every option canvassed. No source consulted confirms a government response to the Carbon Leakage Review, and the absence of one is not evidence of rejection. Threshold, decline rate, target share and budget figures are illustrative options in the paper rather than adopted settings. Nothing in this article is legal, regulatory, accounting or trading advice, and facility-level obligations should be determined with qualified Australian advisers.
Sources
Department of Climate Change, PwC Australia, Clean Energy Regulator
This article is intended for general professional information and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice.
Subscribe to our newsletter for more insights, case studies, and ESG intelligence.
Keep abreast of the top ESG Events on OneStop ESG Events.
OneStop ESG Educate: Your go-to source for top ESG courses and training programs tailored to your needs.
Stay informed with the latest insights on OneStop ESG News.
Discover meaningful career opportunities on OneStop ESG Jobs.

.png%3Falt%3Dmedia%26token%3Db068dc33-4764-4d57-a516-d75b75ceaba3&w=1920&q=90)

.png%3Falt%3Dmedia%26token%3Ddf106b3e-f854-4082-b673-e512a55a0990&w=1920&q=90)

.png%3Falt%3Dmedia%26token%3D79a58d15-a2a6-4f5d-8159-934d176376f5&w=1920&q=90)