The pivotal role of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) standards in shaping responsible mining and long-term value creation was the central theme of discussions at African Mining Week (AMW) 2025. Industry leaders and sustainability experts agreed that well-implemented ESG frameworks not only protect communities and ecosystems but also deliver tangible business benefits for companies across the mineral value chain. However, participants warned that the growing number of ESG frameworks and reporting requirements has led to increasing fragmentation, making it difficult for companies to measure and communicate their true impact. Calls for consolidation and simplification dominated the debate, with panelists emphasizing the need for one unified standard that aligns economic performance with responsible mining practices.

Consolidating Standards for Clarity and Impact

Charlene Wrigley, Vice President of Sustainability Strategy and Disclosures at GoldFields, highlighted that ESG reporting frameworks have already proven instrumental in helping companies quantify and communicate their contributions to sustainable development. Yet she argued that multiple overlapping standards create unnecessary complexity.

“To maximize impact, we need to streamline the system,” Wrigley said, noting that excessive frameworks dilute focus and add reporting burdens without necessarily improving accountability.

She pointed to the work of the Consolidated Mining Standards Initiative (CMSI) as a major step forward. The CMSI seeks to integrate the best elements of four widely used ESG standards into a single global framework, offering clear, comparable, and practical guidance for mining companies of all sizes and across all commodities.

“The CMSI’s final public consultation and last opportunity for industry input on the draft Consolidated Standard, Assurance Process, and Claims Policy launches on 8 October,” she announced. According to Wrigley, the goal is to make ESG reporting more actionable. “ESG has to make good business sense, add value, and be fit-for-purpose. A company’s ESG performance must enable its business strategy and demonstrate impact where it matters most.”

Simplifying Reporting to Strengthen Accountability

Adding to the discussion, Charmane Russell, Founder and Managing Director of R&A Strategic Communications, reflected on the growing difficulty companies face in navigating an expanding maze of sustainability standards.

“The ultimate goal of sustainability reporting is to provide information that is decision-useful,” she said. Russell argued that to achieve comprehensive ESG reporting, companies must evaluate both financial and impact materiality together ensuring boards can fully understand the long-term implications of their environmental and social footprints.

Russell’s perspective echoes a broader industry shift toward integrated reporting, where sustainability performance is presented alongside financial results, reinforcing the idea that ESG is not a separate function but an essential measure of corporate resilience and value creation.

READ MORE: Democratic Financial Officials Reaffirm ESG Commitments in Letter to Asset Managers

Evolving Standards for a Changing Global Context

As ESG frameworks mature, experts expect further evolution focusing on what works and eliminating redundant elements. Pierre Gouws, Associate Director of Sustainable Finance Advisory at SLR Consulting, noted that market realities and investor expectations are continuously refining ESG standards.

“Companies with strong ESG metrics have consistently outperformed those that don’t,” Gouws said. “That tells us ESG is not a trend, it’s a long-term value driver.”

He stressed that sustainability frameworks must evolve to remain practical, outcome-oriented, and aligned with business strategy, shedding what no longer adds value while retaining proven practices.This iterative refinement, he explained, ensures that ESG reporting remains credible and relevant even as technology, regulation, and investor demands shift.

Critical Minerals and the Politics of ESG

Beyond corporate reporting, the discussion turned to the geopolitical dimensions of sustainability in mining. Alex Benkenstein, Head of the Climate and Natural Resources Programme at the South African Institute of International Affairs, emphasized that ESG compliance cannot be divorced from the realities of global competition for critical minerals resources essential for the clean energy transition. He called for greater dialogue between governments, civil society, and industry stakeholders to define what realistic and meaningful ESG compliance looks like across different jurisdictions.

“As competition for access to minerals intensifies, we must not lose sight of the fundamental questions, what ESG means in practice, and who it truly benefits,” Benkenstein cautioned.

His remarks underscored the need for grounded, context-specific engagement to ensure that ESG standards remain both globally credible and locally applicable.

Explore OneStop ESG Marketplace: ESG Reporting

Looking Ahead: From Compliance to Long-Term Value Creation

The panel agreed that while ESG frameworks have made substantial progress in embedding sustainability into mining operations, the next phase must focus on consolidation, comparability, and practical impact. Streamlined standards like the CMSI initiative could become the blueprint for a unified reporting system that reduces administrative burdens while maintaining accountability and transparency. Such alignment would also help investors, regulators, and communities interpret ESG data more effectively, closing the gap between policy ambition and real-world outcomes. Ultimately, participants concluded that the future of mining depends on viewing ESG not as a box-ticking exercise but as a core business strategy, one that safeguards natural resources, supports social development, and strengthens the industry’s long-term license to operate.

Explore ESG Solutions on our marketplace - OneStop ESG Marketplace.

Keep abreast of the top ESG Events on OneStop ESG Events.

OneStop ESG Educate: Your go-to source for top ESG courses and training programs tailored to your needs.

Stay informed with the latest insights on OneStop ESG News.

Discover meaningful career opportunities on OneStop ESG Jobs.