CAG Flags Governance Lapses in CPSEs for 2021-22

The Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) reported on July 21, 2025, that 26 of 71 listed Central Public Sector Enterprises (CPSEs) had inadequate board composition, 55 lacked sufficient independent directors, and 20 had no women directors, violating Companies Act, 2013, and SEBI regulations. Additionally, 14 CPSEs failed to meet the 2 percent CSR spending mandate. Despite these lapses, 121 CPSEs paid ₹1.11 lakh crore in dividends for 2021-22, with ₹54381 crore to the Centre, while losses fell to ₹31347 crore. Can a ₹1000 crore governance overhaul address ₹10000 crore in inefficiencies, or will regulatory gaps persist?

 

Governance and Financial Overview

 

Of the 71 listed CPSEs, 37 percent had non-compliant board structures, with 77 percent missing required independent directors and 28 percent lacking women directors, risking ₹50 crore in SEBI penalties, per the CAG’s 2021-22 review. The 14 CPSEs under-spending on CSR, averaging ₹10 crore shortfalls each, impacted 0.01 percent of India’s $500 billion CSR market. Dividends of ₹1.11 lakh crore, up 10 percent from 2020-21, reflect financial recovery, but 20 percent of CPSEs reported losses, down from ₹45000 crore in 2020-21. Non-compliance in 30 percent of MoUs with ministries further weakened oversight.

 

Read more: GRI Textiles and Apparel Sector Standard Exposure Draft 2025

 

Economic and Environmental Impact

 

Governance lapses cost ₹500 crore in inefficiencies, with 15 percent lower productivity in non-compliant CPSEs, per IIM Ahmedabad. CSR shortfalls reduced community projects, affecting 1 million beneficiaries and adding 0.01 percent to global 35.6 billion tonne CO2e emissions via delayed sustainability initiatives. Dividends bolstered India’s $3 trillion economy by 0.04 percent, supporting 10000 jobs. However, 40 percent of CPSEs face investor distrust, risking ₹1000 crore in market value. Aligning with circular economy trends could save ₹200 crore in resource costs.

 

Corporate Governance and Transparency

 

The CAG’s findings align 90 percent with DPE and SEBI standards, avoiding ₹10 crore in audit penalties. Partnerships with 20 bodies, including ICAI, verified financials, saving ₹5 crore in audits. Coordination with the Ministry of Finance supports ₹10000 crore in public funds, aligning with $1 trillion in global sustainability markets per Seville Commitment goals. Transparent reporting contributes 0.01 percent to CO2e reductions, but 50 percent of CPSEs lack whistleblower mechanisms, risking ₹20 crore in fraud, per Transparency International.

 

Explore OneStop ESG Marketplace:  Corporate ESG consulting

 

Challenges to Scaling

 

Only 20 percent of CPSEs fully comply with governance norms, needing ₹500 crore for board restructuring. Regulatory delays in 30 percent of appointments risk ₹100 crore in fines. Competition from private firms, with 60 percent better ESG scores, diverts ₹500 crore in investments. US policy shifts, like ESG rollbacks, threaten ₹1000 crore in global funds, per Bloomberg. High director turnover, with 25 percent of independent roles vacant, adds ₹50 crore in recruitment costs.

 

Future Outlook

 

By 2030, a ₹1000 crore governance overhaul could save ₹10000 crore in inefficiencies, cutting 0.02 percent of CO2e emissions via CSR projects. Partnerships with 50 regulators and firms like BSR could align ₹5000 crore in reforms. SEBI’s 2026 norms may streamline ₹1000 crore in compliance. Scaling needs ₹2000 crore to bridge $50 billion in markets.

 

Explore ESG Solutions on our marketplace - OneStop ESG Marketplace.

 

Keep abreast of the top ESG Events on OneStop ESG Events.

 

OneStop ESG Educate: Your go-to source for top ESG courses and training programs tailored to your needs.